For over three decades, Angelina’s Pizzeria has stood as Old Key West’s premier destination for the freshest, most mouthwatering pizza, nestled in the vibrant heart of Duval Street. Committed to exceptional quality, Angelina’s handcrafts its pizza crust daily, creating the perfect foundation for an extensive menu that includes delicious pizzas, crisp salads, hearty pastas, satisfying subs, customizable options, and savory calzones. Conveniently located near Key West’s top resorts and hotels, Angelina’s Pizzeria caters to every craving, whether it’s a hearty lunch, a delightful dinner, or a late-night treat after enjoying the island’s lively festivities. Patrons can enjoy late-night deliveries, quick bites before sunset at Mallory Square, or relax with arcade games and a serene turtle pond while savoring their favorite dishes. Additionally, Angelina’s enhances the local culture with its original podcast, "Sit With Kit," hosted by Kit Carson, the Earl of Pizza, who interviews Key West’s rock stars, heroes, and iconic personalities from the beloved pizzeria’s front porch. The vibrant atmosphere is perfect for people-watching and creating unforgettable memories with loved ones. Established over thirty years ago at the bustling corner of Greene and Duval, just across from Sloppy Joe’s, Angelina’s Pizzeria continues to reign supreme as the ultimate pizza paradise, serving homemade goodness seven days a week from 11:00 am until the early hours. Whether you’re indulging in a single slice or a full meal, Angelina’s Pizzeria promises a slice of pizza heaven, making it an essential stop for anyone seeking an authentic and delectable Key West experience. Discover why Angelina’s Pizzeria is truly “The Best Piece In Town!”
