The Mermaid & The Alligator Bed & Breakfast

The Key West Collection by Riley provides a distinguished hospitality experience with dedicated service, comfortable accommodations, and amenities included in every daily room rate—never burdening guests with hidden fees or resort charges. Each historic Old Town property boasts its own charm, offering personalized concierge services, refreshing pools, breakfast, free Wi-Fi, and more. In particular, The Mermaid & The Alligator stands out as an adults-only bed and breakfast, featuring nine unique rooms in a beautifully preserved Victorian home. Visitors can wander through lush gardens teeming with tropical flowers and exotic birds, unwind in an oversized hammock or chaise lounge, and cool off in the plunge pool. Located just three blocks from Duval Street, this serene retreat allows easy access to Key West’s famed beaches, shops, galleries, and culinary delights. From planning exhilarating snorkeling excursions to sharing heartfelt stories inspired by their stay, guests are treated to a seamless blend of comfort, transparency, and memorable moments at The Mermaid & The Alligator—truly a place to “make new memories” in Key West.